February 7, 2013

STEAM Academy

(Photo by Meg O'Neil)

Barbara McGann, a founding member of the Newport County STEAM Academy charter school (left), and Joanne Hoops (at right), another founding member and executive director of the Newport Boys & Girls Club.

By Meg O’Neil

Newport is one step closer to opening a new charter school in 2014. It was announced on Monday, Feb. 4 that the Rhode Island Department of Education had formally accepted the initial planning Prospectus for the Newport County STEAM Academy – a school that will specialize in Science, Technology, Engineering, Arts, and Mathematics.

With the approval, the Academy will now prepare a final proposal to be submitted to the Department of Education by March 1. As part of the review and approval process, the Department of Education and Commissioner Deborah Gist will conduct several public hearings in Newport, allowing county residents to voice their opinion on the idea of the charter school.

If the school gets full approval, it expects to open its doors at the Newport County Boys & Girls Club facility at 95 Church St. on Historic Hill by September 2014. To start, the school will cater to elementary aged students through grade 8, adding a high school grade level in subsequent years at a separate location somewhere on Aquidneck Island. Looking even further ahead, the school could also add a grade 13 to offer students an Associates’ Degree by partnering with area colleges. 

If approved, it will become the 17th charter school in the state, and be part of a growing movement nationally to recast education. 

In recent years, charter schools across the country that had come to be known as STEM schools have pushed towards a STEAM model – paying particular mind to the intersection of art and design and how they relate to with business and technology.

The Newport County STEAM Academy plans to use the Boys & Girls Club building during school hours. The building will continue to operate as the Boys & Girls Club in the afternoon as an afterschool facility.

According to the Prospectus, the building on Church Street was opened in 1874 and was one of the first co-educational public high schools in the state established exclusively for college preparation. Today, the Boys & Girls Club facility has been refurbished with wireless computer labs, updated classrooms, art space, full-sized gymnasium, teen center, kitchen, and large indoor swimming pool.

Boys & Girls Club Executive Director Joanne Hoopes said the partnership will allow for the afterschool program to continue what they do now. “This is a great opportunity for us to work directly with teachers and support what they’re doing during the school day and gear our afterschool activities to be a continuation of what was learned during class,” she said.

The Boys & Girls Club will be used to house the lower elementary classrooms. Space for upper grade levels is still being sought. Classroom space may be available at the Corporate Park in Middletown, or the possibility exists of using one of the existing elementary schools in Newport that will be closed when the new Pell Elementary School opens this fall.

A team of founding members began planning for the Newport County STEAM Academy last year as a community effort. Two of them are Barbara McGann and Middletown Councilman Chris Semonelli.

McGann, a Newport native and retired Navy Rear Admiral, was previously the assistant superintendent of Boston Public Schools, CEO of the Marlborough, Mass. public schools and most recently founded the Advanced Math and Science Academy in Marlborough in 2005.

McGann says her goal is to create the premier model STEAM School for the state of Rhode Island.

To do that, the Newport STEAM Academy aims to use fabrication labs to foster manufacturing skills, science labs, and to become a “very hands on, real world, problem solving school." 

Partnering and collaborating with other area schools and universities such as the Rhode Island School of Design and Salve Regina University, as well as local businesses, will be key to the success of the STEAM Academy, McGann said.

“The jobs that our kids are going to have aren’t even invented yet,” she says. “It used to be acceptable to prepare children with basic skills to go on to college and then join the workforce. That’s just not enough anymore in a global economy. We’ve got to be graduating critical thinkers and problem solvers.”

McGann said she has a simple formula that will allow for the STEAM Academy to succeed:

“Setting incredibly high standards; Effective instruction and hiring the best teachers you can find; Teachers have to know how to continuously use data and student work to inform instruction; and most importantly, you’ve got to have powerful, positive relationships through the school – from the janitors to the school leader. You’ve got to make sure there is a caring, loving adult in the life of every single child.”

Operating as an independent charter school and open to all students in Newport County, the STEAM Academy would not belong to the Newport Public School District, but would operate independently under the governance of an appointed board. The STEAM Academy already is seeking a school principal. Once they have been approved by the Department of Education, new charter schools can receive funding up to $400,000 to help develop curriculum and to make building updates.

With no collective bargaining or teacher unions or teacher seniority, McGann said that charter schools are able to operate with “tremendous freedom and flexibility.” In exchange for that flexibility, the Rhode Island Department of Education has higher expectations from charter schools compared to their public school counterparts. “The Department of Education expects you to outperform the public school districts that send students to the charter school – which we intend to do,” she said.  

Additionally, McGann said the state standards are set much higher than the common core. “When you set very high standards, students will stretch to meet them,” she said.

According to Councilman Semonelli, if charter schools do not exceed their set standards within five years, the schools are forced to close. “This is an aggressive undertaking, and we have to exceed the standards. Ultimately, the students will benefit from that,” he said.

The Newport Country STEAM Academy would be like a public school in that there is no tuition. Instead, designated public funds follow the child. The per pupil cost varies from district to district. Newport has one of the highest per pupil costs in the state, hovering around $20,000.

Because of the way funds are allocated to charter schools, public opinion on them tends to be mixed.

Speaking for himself, Newport School Superintendent John H. Ambrogi said that he is generally not a fan of charter schools. “I feel charter schools siphon off much-needed money for public education, and I think if people focused more on public schools that exist, and were more active and aggressive in terms of their involvement, then we could achieve what people in charter schools are trying to achieve.”

However, Ambrogi also pointed out that if the STEAM Academy could be a “game changer” in terms of a forecast in future enrollment for Newport public schools. “Everyone has been clamoring about how the new Pell School is not large enough … the proposed charter school could have a substantial impact on our numbers,” Ambrogi said.

With approximately 2,200 currently enrolled in Newport public schools, Ambrogi said he is concerned with the impact a charter school in Newport could have on an already small district.

For Semonelli, the idea of charter school on Aquidneck Island and available to all students in the county makes sense, especially after regionalization efforts have so often failed. “By the time the public school budget money goes through all the filters and reaches the students, the money just isn’t there ... I’m not taking anything away from our current teachers – they’re just encumbered with regulations and it ties their hands. Our objective is to untie their hands,” he said. “The STEAM Academy will give us the flexibility that I’ve been trying to accomplish from across the table with school committees.”

The STEAM Academy has received initial planning approval from the Department of Education, but final word on their March 1 proposal is not expected for several months. If the Department declines the STEAM Academy proposal, the charter school can resubmit a proposal by December 1.

The community is invited to attend an open house at the Newport Boys & Girls Club at 95 Church St. on Wednesday, Feb. 13. At 5:30 p.m., McGann will provide an overview of the school. Childcare and refreshments will be provided.

February 7, 2013

Comments (37)

Comment Feed

Resume? Might try

"Tools" then "Spelling and Grammar" first.

The past tense of lead is led, and "that make ten years" could also use some work.

Looks like you'll fit right into the entire program.

Concerned Taxpayer 60 days ago

Resume

I am a laid off teacher in Newport. I am a secondary certified Biology and General Science teacher. I did a summer STEM training program in 2006. Yes, I am ahead of the game! I have lead an after school robotics program (privately funded) since my first year, that make 10 years. I obtained an MS in education and tend to be a progressive out of the box teacher. Where can I send a resume?

Newport Teacher 61 days ago

Conflict of interest?

When you read the BGCA code of ethics you have to wonder if Ms. Hoopes is in violation or soon will be.

Taxpayer 83 days ago

Watch out for the ACLU!

Between Salve involvement and the facility being the Boys & Girls Club... you can bet the ACLU will be sniffing around to see how your tax dollar is contributing to a secular education. Remember Cranston's prayer banner? The Boys & Girls Club 'code' reads:
"I believe in God and the right to worship according to my own faith and religion."

PJ 83 days ago

I'm going to assume

that the advocates of this charter school have actually read one or two of the studies by Rand and the Dept of Education that discuss charter schools; if not, here's the link, again:

http://www.rand.org/topics/charter-schools.html

Why are some averse to this concept? Because charter schools educate children no better than the public school system. Because they directly take resources from the public school system and give these tax dollars to private corporations. Because charter schools remove worker protections from educators. Because charter schools have none of the constraints that we have imposed on the public schools with respect to teaching the disabled, educationally and otherwise handicapped. Because charter schools can cherry pick their choice of students and there's no guarantee, Newport Mother of 3, et al, that yours are one of them.

Charter schools are businesses. They are publicly funded, limited enrollment "academies" that perform no better and in some cases worse than the public schools they aim to replace. While there is absolutely no defense for the comical performance of our own school administration, the answer is not found in the charter school concept.

Concerned Taxpayer 84 days ago

About time

Wow, how come so much negativity about an alternative school? Look how long it has taken the Newport and Aquidneck Island community to wake up to the needs of the school-aged children. Middle School Thompson took forever to get renovated, elementary school Pell school is only under construction and regional high school is going nowhere. Who is thinking about the future of our children. Education is their only chance. Why criticize those who are taking action? The children of Newport deserve a fighting chance. Parents don't stand a chance against the bureaucracy of the current administration and teachers unions. "If you can't fight 'em, beat 'em"... Instead of sitting around, grousing about what is, these folks are fighting for what can be. Not willing to wait around for others to take action, they are taking local education into their own hands. Hooray! It's about time. Full STEAM ahead!

Newport mother of 3 84 days ago

ofrJwCPHphPKTLw

We definitely need more smart people like you aonrud.

Kaley 94 days ago

charter school

In yesterday's Newport Daily News article, McGann is quoted as saying, "I'm not a charter school advocate. I'm a great school advocate.". Well, then, why doesn't she buckle down with the rest of us and do the hard, right thing: work to improve our existing public schools rather than diminish them? This whole proposal stinks of nothing but selfishness and self-interest.

mad dad 94 days ago

Old school idea

The reason NPS abandonned the idea of renovating the old schools is because they are not fire code compliant, contain lead and asbesos, the basements are unusable, and fed regulations no longer allow small children above the first floor. The Station Fire changed the way the buildings could be used. To bring any of the buildings into compliance would be tremendously costly. These people have not thought anything through. They are just throwing out statements that sound good, but any one with any experience knows that their proposal is full of holes. Ridiculous.

Mom 95 days ago

Facility plans

Boys club will only house lower elementary grades and maybe they'll find additional space in the industrial park or a closed school for upper grades. Then they will figure out high school facilities. I would hope a navy flag officer would walk away from this half baked idea before their reputation is tarnished. Maybe ambrogi can run this school after retirement. He can't do any worse than he has for Newport public schools.

Taxpayer 95 days ago

Elected official

Perhaps the elected official being referred to is Chris Semonelli. I would hope no elected officials in Newport would support weakening our public schools.

Resident 95 days ago

Transparancy

Someone's going to have to face the public and offer transparency if they want the approval of Ms. Gist. Perhaps the organizers read some of these comments and decided they ought to get their act together before going public? There's a lot to be addressed here. Starting a school is no easy task. I'm also curious as to exactly who the 'elected official' is on their board.

Brinker Hadley 95 days ago

Weather?

Perhaps it is true that the weather has something to do with the cancellation, but if I were involved in this group, I would not be too anxious to "show off" the Boys and Girls Club. My kids used the pool for a short time when it was closed due to mold. It got cleaned up but the building is not very impressive. Also.....they say that this school is k to 12? Remember the outrage when the 5th graders were going to go to school with big bad 8th graders?? Come on, the only transparency here is the desire to have their own private school. Here we are going to have a brand new school wired for modern technology and equipment, a media center, and will be lead and asbestos free. What people won't do to not support the public schools.

Mom 95 days ago

charter school

I see in today's Newport Daily News that STEAM has cancelled their previously scheduled Wednesday meet and greet at the Boys' and Girls' Club due to "the weather". So much for public involvement and transparency.

Navy mom 95 days ago

Student transportation

I will be interested to see how many Portsmouth and Middletown residents put their kids on a bus to the boys club. And who pays the cost of the bus transportation. Given the near equal enrollments in island schools this school should be required to have 1/3 enrollment from each community if it isheldto it's advertised Aquidneck island school status.

Island resident 96 days ago

Great for newport

I think this is a great idea for newport and would welcome another option for school for our children. Hoping this moves forward!!!

Newport Mom 96 days ago

Home school?

If you can't afford one of the fine private schools here on the island or in this State, then either get involved with the public system to improve it, or home school your child. Don't re-invent the wheel because you got a flat. Change the tire! These people are siphoning off taxpayer's money that will be difficult to follow. The other thing that struck me as odd - their FAQ page cites a student - teacher ratio of about 15 or 20 to 1. It later says how every student will have a custom tailored curriculum. How do you teach like that? I'm sure a teacher could try an answer that one. I'm sure charter schools have their place and successes, but it doesn't appear as though this group has it all together. The public information meetings will be interesting to attend!

Overtaxed 96 days ago

RE:

I just hope that if this Charter School idea goes forward, our county administrators will write in a provision that, in the event of termination (whether by convenience or default), the building used for the Charter School will be turned into condos.

FRED SULLIVAN 96 days ago

charter school

Well I have read all the literature on the charter school and think hey why not. I am all for it, Change is what is needed, or a new superintendent that knows what the heck is going on in schools...

Newport resident 96 days ago

Ok, I'll bite

"...even those schools’ leaders would concede that a comparison to the local public school fails to account for uneven special-needs and ELL populations, and an uneven distribution of students with family support."

"Charters are the new force of privatization of public schools complete with its own legislative lobby—most notably a cabal of hedge fund managers innocuously named Democrats for Education Reform, whose director now famously quipped to the New York Times, “If you’re at a hedge fund, [charter schools are] definitely the hot cause.”

http://www.principals.org/Content.aspxtopic=The_Charter_School_Spin_Factor

"Recent studies across multiple states by Stanford University, the Rand Corporation and the U.S. Department of Education show that, on average, charter school students do no better or worse than their counterparts at traditional public schools in the same communities — unless they’re poor."

http://www.psmag.com/education/a-s-and-f-s-for-charter-schools-24640/

And, for those that "consider themselves educated" on the topic, here's some studies from Rand. Try reading them.

http://www.rand.org/topics/charter-schools.html

Concerned Taxpayer 96 days ago

Charter School

What I find just sad - is when people consider themselves educated (which they may be in some areas - but not this one) and voice their opinions. If you don't know anything about charter schools - please go read how successful they are and the locations.
People think Newport is great - it is, except when it comes to public schools. The national high school graduation rate is 78% with RI's graduation rate of 76% - If you think that is good - you're very wrong.
If more people were concerned about how poorly run the schools are in Newport (or even the state) - the idea of a charter school wouldn't have come about because something would have already been done. But people are afraid to hold people accountable or be held accountable themselves. Look at the rate of home schoolers? It's not only for religious reasons which is about 30% of homeschoolers - There is another 50% who homeschool because of the poorly run school district.
The first thing military members are told about Newport when they get orders here is how bad the schools are. Do you think that is for nothing? Moving as often as we have and being in so many school districts - you can see what makes a successful school. Parents! Good, accountable, productive teachers! A strong - responsible school district! There are many variables that come together to provide a "good" school -

Newport Mom 96 days ago

Yes!

Bravo, Navy Mom!!

Resident 97 days ago

charter school

As a middle school teacher and Navy wife who has lived and taught in towns across the US, I can tell you from personal experience that charter schools are nothing but slickly promoted business ventures that profit the few at the expense of our children. Newporters, send these "educators" packing ASAP and concentrate your energies on supporting the PUBLIC education system.

Navy mom 97 days ago

Follow the money...

It will be very interesting to see (if approved) just how transparent the finances of this will be. Charter Schools are big business and seem to be getting bigger - consulting firms, management companies, support services, hedge funds and private equity investment - all playing with taxpayer's money. Sounds scary.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/02/private-firms-eyeing-prof_n_1732856.html

Phineas 97 days ago

Cocerned Taxpayert

If you oppose the Charter school concept that is all well and good, but it is certainly unnecessary to hold up Rear Admiral McGann to ridicule and scorn. Admiral McGann has had a outstanding career both in the Navy, where she obviously excelled, and in the field of education where she has made an excellent contribution.

She served as assistant superintendent of schools in Boston, one of the countries larger systems. That she refused to be the whipping boy of non professional politicians who sought to second guess her every move as an educator, by resigning as Superintendent of the Marlborough schools, speaks positively about her character and interigrity as a professional, and can only be a criticied those ignorant of the situation. She served as the very successful CEO of a Charter school.,

Admiral McGann seeks only to use her ability and recognized skills to help the City she loves, and which her mother served as Mayor, and the County her father served as sheriff, to establish a high quality Charter school to benefit the children of this community. There is no hidden agenda here to benefit herself.

Most places would be grateful to have such a resource.

Critic's Critic 98 days ago

Wake up call

If nothing else this should be a wake up call to the newport school department. After years of nothing but closing schools and cutting education programs we've been left with a shell of a school system. Get a superintendent that understands poverty, education and technology instead of padding the pockets of an out of touch has been.

Unhappy customer 99 days ago

Much needed alternative

While funding issues are a concern, they are no bigger than the concern many parents have with the education that our children are getting in the Aquidneck Island public schools. In the five years that my children have been in school, I have been underwhelmed by the effort that goes into teaching them and the breadth of the curriculum. If proper planning goes into this project it could be just what the island needs!

Julie 99 days ago

Gist

I would hope that Commissioner Gist sees that this school is nothing more than a power/money grab with zero upsides for most of the kids in the Newport Public Schools. Has anyone approached the school department to see if a program like this can be brought to the public schools??

Steamed 99 days ago

Just say no

Suppose RADM McGann has nothing in this hunt? If this abomination of an idea comes to pass, we should note her resume. Our tax money should not be used to support another $140k retirement job for a bored RADM.

Barbara McGann, the retired Navy rear admiral and former Boston administrator who lasted less than two years as superintendent of Marlborough's public schools, last week took charge of a charter school..."

http://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2008/05/25/mcgann_takes_helm_of_charter_school/

"In her case, the departure appears to be connected to a tense relationship with the School Committee."

http://www.boston.com/news/local/articles/2008/02/14/sign_of_times_at_schools_superintendent_wanted/?page=full

Concerned (as always) Taxpayer 99 days ago

Pay up!

If you want your kid to have a private school education, break out the checkbook and pony up the $$ for a private school. But taking taxpayer money to fund a private 'charter' school is very selfish and inconsiderate of the other students in our public schools, their teachers - and the taxpayers!

Fred 100 days ago

Inclusivness & Diversity?

All interesting points being raised here. It will be interesting to see when & if this school is established, if the ethnic diversity shown by the photo above the article is present in the student body. My guess is probably not. According to the web site they have, there's no admissions test and some sort of lottery for others when (if) they reach capacity. So who decides who gets to attend? There's not a lot that's clear about this.

Phineas 100 days ago

Inclusiveness

inclusiveness???? I doubt that is the point of this school. I would venture to say that the point is just the opposite. Why is this school being proposed? I fear this school proposal is based on a desire to have their private school with total contol. This is a very cynical move.

Resident 100 days ago

Inclusiveness

I can see the concerns made by other comments regarding both the need for more parental involvement in local schools and the potential loss of revenue. My main concern is how inclusive this school will be. I don't recognize any of the community minority leaders on the board for this school and haven't heard of any plans to recruit students from the north end/Newport Heights area.

Given the poor track record of the current administration (highest cost per student in the state AND the worst performing elementary school in the state) it is not surprising to see this concept evolve. Finding new school leadership for Newport is the real solution. Hopefully his school does not become Cluny North but rather is representative of the student minority and poverty rates in local schools. Perhaps "Opt Out" enrollment in the lottery system for students would be appropriate.

Taxpayer 100 days ago

Boys and girls club?

How would the Boys and Girls club accommodate this program? I sincerely hope the Dept of Ed sees the light and realizes that this school would only benefit a few and would cause nothing but damage to our public schools. Bigger communities can absorb a charter but a small community like Newport would be put at risk. Shame. Shame. If you think your kids are too good for the Newport Public Schools, use your own wallets. Not mine.

Steamed too 100 days ago

Questionable...

I can't help but see this as the brainchild of folks who want their kids to have a private school education on the taxpayer's dime. There are some decent private schools on the island already. And typically, Charter Schools are reimbursed on a per head basis - at about sixty cents on the dollar. In this world where many careers are driven by economic motives, how do they expect to get the best teachers? Ambrogi said it best: " if people focused more on public schools that exist, and were more active and aggressive in terms of their involvement, then we could achieve what people in charter schools are trying to achieve.”

Phineas 100 days ago

steamed also

I agree with STEAMed parent. This is nothing more than some parents wanting their own private school. This would be a disaster in a small community like Newport. Selfish beyond belief. Support your public schools!

npt resident 100 days ago

charter "school"

This would be disastrous for Newport's already stressed public school system. Charter "schools" are nothing more than scams to funnel federal and state dollars into the hands of private businesses. I'm certain that McGann and Cullen have written themselves into this deal; they're not doing this out of the goodness of their hearts.

STEAMed parent 100 days ago

Education Blog Header
Location Search
Latest Tweets
    Built with Metro Publisher™